Nancy Fish – Biography, Family, Facts About P.T Barnum’s Wife

Nancy Fish was the wife of P.T Barnum, an American showman, businessman, and politician whose real name is Phineas Taylor Barnum. She was born on April 22, 1850, and died on June 23, 1927, at 77 years of age. Nancy Fish was the daughter of a well-known cotton miller and became even more prominent after her marriage to P.T Barnum, who was 40 years her senior. 

The enormous age difference between Nancy Fish and her husband caused quite a stir at the time, considering that he was her father’s close friend and his second wife. It was all the more scandalous because the two had been dating long before the death of his first wife. Contrary to the negative criticism they received, the two lived together happily until his death in 1891.

Summary of Nancy Fish’s Bio

  • Full Name: Nancy Fish Barnum Callias D’Orengiani
  • Nickname: Nancy Fish (Baroness)
  • Gender: Female
  • Date of Birth: April 22, 1850
  • Died: June 23, 1927
  • Ethnicity: White
  • Nationality: British-American
  • Zodiac Sign: Pisces
  • Sexual Orientation: Straight
  • Religion: Greek Orthodox Church
  • Marital Status: Married
  • Nancy Fish’s Husband: Phineas Taylor Barnum
  • Nancy Fish’s Children: Natasha Silver
  • Nancy Fish’s Parents: 
  • Siblings: Martha (née Shaw) and John Fish
  • Famous for: Being P.T Barnum’s Wife and an English Socialite

Who Was Nancy Fish?

P.T. Barnum’s second wife was born as Nancy Alexandry Orengiani in the industrial city of Blackburn, Lancashire, England on 22nd April 1850 to her parents Martha Shaw and John Fish. Nancy Fish was the second child of three born to her parents.

Nancy Fish’s ethnicity and nationality, she was a British-American citizen. Though much is not known about her educational background, from the records, the beautiful damsel was very good at letter writing.

Furthermore, Nancy’s meteoric rise to fame came about as a result of her much-publicized marriage to the renowned businessman and promoter, P.T. Barnum who is also known as The Greatest Showman. She was married as the second wife of the accomplished promoter after his first wife, Charity Barnum died from heart failure. Prior to her marriage to one of the wealthiest men of the 19th century, Nancy Fish worked at her father’s cotton mill. Also, she was the one who engraved the name, Barnum on one of their machines in adoration of the successful showman.

Nancy Fish’s Family

Nancy Fish was the second daughter of her parents, Martha Shaw and John Fish. She was raised together with her two siblings in Lancashire and their names are; Jane Fish, born in 1846 and John Fish, born in 1861 and died in 1914. Her father was an educated and fulfilled businessman who owned a few number of cotton mills in Lancashire. Nancy’s father credited the success of his cotton mill business to P.T. Barnum whom he got inspiration from after studying his autobiography. Fish helped her father out in the production of cotton together with her elder sister, Jane.

Other Facts About P.T. Barnum’s Wife

1. Nancy Fish’s marriage to P.T. Barnum

Nancy Fish
Nancy Fish and P.T Barnum

Nancy Fish wedded with P.T. Barnum twice. She got acquainted with P. T. Barnum through her father who was P.T. Barnum’s close pal and it was reported that the duo had been in a relationship before the death of P.T. Barnum’s first wife, Charity Barnum on 19th November 1873. However, the greatest showman wrote in his autobiography that they were in constant communication through writing and that Nancy Fish used to accompany him to some of his European tours.

Soon after the death of his first wife whom he did not attend her burial, P.T. Barnum exchanged marital vows with his mistress, Nancy on 14th February 1874 in a private wedding held at The Strand, London in the presence of John and Martha Fish.

Then on 15th September in the same year, P.T. Barnum tied the knot for the second time with Nancy Fish, this time in the presence of a mammoth crowd in the Greek Orthodox church named Church of the Divine Paternity, Fifth Avenue, New York officiated by his good friend Rev. Dr. Chapin.

Almost soon after the wedding, they went on a honeymoon at the Windsor Hotel, New York. The couple lived happily together before the death of the professional showman, P.T. Barnum on 7th April 1891.

2. Nancy Fish’s Relationship with Demetrius Callias Bey

Four years after the death of her husband, Nancy Fish exchanged marital vows again with Demetrius Callias Bey in a secret wedding held at Annunciation Greek Orthodox Church, New York officiated by Fr. Agatheodoro Papageorgopoulos. The two lovebirds met when Callias got hold of Nancy after falling off the Great Pyramid during her visit to Egypt. Their great love life was short-lived as Callias died barely after one year of their marriage on the 22nd of September, 1896 from a liver-related ailment.

3. Nancy Fish’s Third Marriage

P.T. Barnum’s widow remarried again. This time to a French baron named Lucien Hippolyte Ferdinand. Their marriage was a contract one being that Nancy Fish paid off the baron’s debt in order to become a baroness.

4. Her special love for Demetrius Callias Bey

Nancy Fish passed away in 1927. Before her death, she stated that she should be incinerated and buried next to her second husband, Demetrius Callias Bey whom she loved so much and not alongside P.T. Barnum.

In summary, Nancy Fish was significantly younger than Barnum, who was born in 1810. After the death of his first wife, Charity Hallett Barnum, in 1873, Barnum married Nancy Fish in 1874. Despite the significant age gap (Barnum was 64 and Fish was 24 at the time of their marriage), they reportedly had a happy marriage.

After Barnum’s death in 1891, Nancy Fish continued to live in their Connecticut home until her own death in 1927.

Chioma Uchenwoke
Chioma Uchenwoke
With several years of experience as a writer - I bring an interesting mix of skills to each project that allows me to create compelling content tailored specifically for personal bios, entertainment topics and travel


Featured Today

Featured Today

Related Stories